Fabian,

Here are my results:
sql>select * from target;
+------+-----+-----------------------+
| toto |titi |value                  |
+======+=====+=======================+
| 1    |1    |                    48 |
| 1    |2    |                    48 |
| 2    |1    |                    48 |
| 2    |2    |                    48 |
| 2    |3    |                    48 |
+------+-----+-----------------------+
Timer      47.000 msec 5 rows
sql>select * from targetos;
+------+-----+-----------------------+
| tata |tutu |value                  |
+======+=====+=======================+
| 1    |1    |                    10 |
| 1    |2    |                     8 |
| 2    |1    |                    10 |
| 2    |2    |                    10 |
| 2    |3    |                    10 |
+------+-----+-----------------------+
Timer      63.000 msec 5 rows

Basically in the first query, monetdb doesn't correctly join the source table with the target table
but it does on the second.

On Wed, Sep 3, 2008 at 9:41 AM, Fabian Groffen <Fabian.Groffen@cwi.nl> wrote:
Hi Christophe,

Thanks for your interest in MonetDB.

On 02-09-2008 23:38:56 +0200, Christophe Galerne wrote:
> I am copying some sample SQL which illustrates what I believe is a bug:
> #######################################################################
> #########
> CREATE TABLE SOURCE
> (
>     TOTO    VARCHAR(5),
>     TITI     VARCHAR(5),
>     VALUE    DOUBLE
> );
>
> INSERT INTO SOURCE VALUES('1', '1', 5.0) , ('1', '2', 4.0), ('2', '1',
> 5.0), ('2', '2', 5.0), ('2', '3', 5.0);
> INSERT INTO SOURCE VALUES('1', '1', 5.0) , ('1', '2', 4.0), ('2', '1',
> 5.0), ('2', '2', 5.0), ('2', '3', 5.0);
>
> CREATE TABLE TARGET
> (
>     TOTO    VARCHAR(5),
>     TITI     VARCHAR(5),
>     VALUE    DOUBLE
> );
>
> INSERT INTO TARGET VALUES('1', '1', 0) , ('1', '2', 0), ('2', '1', 0),
> ('2', '2', 0), ('2', '3', 0);
>
> UPDATE TARGET SET VALUE = ( SELECT SUM(VALUE) FROM SOURCE WHERE TOTO=
> SOURCE.TOTO and TITI=SOURCE.TITI);
>
> CREATE TABLE TARGETOS
> (
>     TATA    VARCHAR(5),
>     TUTU     VARCHAR(5),
>     VALUE    DOUBLE
> );
>
> INSERT INTO TARGETOS VALUES('1', '1', 0) , ('1', '2', 0), ('2', '1',
> 0), ('2', '2', 0), ('2', '3', 0);
>
> UPDATE TARGETOS SET VALUE = ( SELECT SUM(VALUE) FROM SOURCE WHERE
> SOURCE.TOTO=TATA and SOURCE.TITI=TUTU);
> #######################################################################
> #########
>
> The expected results is for the tables TARGET and TARGETOS to contain
> the same result since
> they only differ by the name of their columns.  It seems that monetdb
> gets confused by the fact that
> table SOURCE and table TARGET have the column names.

What is the error you're seeing?  You describe what you expect to see,
but not what actually comes out.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
This SF.Net email is sponsored by the Moblin Your Move Developer's challenge
Build the coolest Linux based applications with Moblin SDK & win great prizes
Grand prize is a trip for two to an Open Source event anywhere in the world
http://moblin-contest.org/redirect.php?banner_id=100&url=/
_______________________________________________
MonetDB-users mailing list
MonetDB-users@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/monetdb-users